ADVERTISEMENT
返回
  • 浏览过的版块

123
Huaren
等级贵宾大校
威望165
贴子109088
魅力124870
注册时间2004-07-29

疏影暗香

只看他

2004-09-12 21:31:00

以下是引用jd2002在2004-9-12 20:32:51的发言:
如果有人看完《十面埋伏》还说是好片就奇怪了

Huaren
等级三等兵
威望--
贴子195
魅力622
注册时间2004-03-12

mimiyian

只看他

2004-09-13 14:19:00

The script, the action are just so so.
However, the scenery, the CGI, the color are spectacular. Director Zhang really knows how to use his camera.
Wondering where they went for the shooting. Some scenes are so out of the worldly.
Huaren
等级贵宾大校
威望40
贴子7014
魅力9637
注册时间2002-10-20

Chanel

只看他

2004-09-13 14:53:00

以下是引用mimiyian在2004-9-13 14:19:44的发言:
The script, the action are just so so.
However, the scenery, the CGI, the color are spectacular. Director Zhang really knows how to use his camera.
Wondering where they went for the shooting. Some scenes are so out of the worldly.




再好看也抵不上情节烂呀
我在国内看得
基本上电影院就是从头笑到尾
尤其后面“交党费”死不了那段
Huaren
等级上校
威望5
贴子4080
魅力4671
注册时间2004-05-18

unknownMM

只看他

2004-09-13 17:15:00

呵呵,我们看得时候更搞笑,朋友说,就算古代物质条件不好,也请找个房子再躺来躺去,
或者买个被子也成。
奇怪的是,韩国朋友看了,说很唯美。估计是故事情节看不懂,看风景那么美。。。
Huaren
等级三等兵
威望--
贴子195
魅力622
注册时间2004-03-12

mimiyian

只看他

2004-09-13 17:16:00

以下是引用Chanel在2004-9-13 14:53:55的发言:

再好看也抵不上情节烂呀
我在国内看得
基本上电影院就是从头笑到尾
尤其后面“交党费”死不了那段


I guess this movie, just like "Hero", is not meant for Chinese audience, but for international viewers.

It is just a movie meant for "export".

Maybe the success of "crouching tiger, hidden dragon" makes Zhang realize this type of movie can really sell!
There is no need of a good script, no need to make sense, but only need,
1. plenty of KongFu,
2. a love story,
3. beatuiful scenery, focus on BAMBOO forest! as they are considered to be exotic and unusual.
and therefore BAMBOO fighting (not sure whether people are already sick of this).
4. oversimpified historical events so that it won't be too changlendging for simple-minded foreign audience.
Huaren
等级等待验证会员
威望8
贴子4420
魅力5551
注册时间2004-02-20

bearhouse

只看他

2004-09-13 17:31:00

以下是引用Chanel在2004-9-13 14:53:55的发言:
再好看也抵不上情节烂呀
我在国内看得
基本上电影院就是从头笑到尾
尤其后面“交党费”死不了那段


我也是在国内看的。因为是第一二天看的,人很多,而且外国人特别多。有美,日,韩等等。只记得全电影院都在笑,还有老外说怎么这么funny啊,都赶上comedy了。实在是有些奇怪它在日韩的票房怎么这么好。

我个人觉得十面埋伏在拍摄手法上完全没有超越英雄,而且有的地方有些走火入魔了。例如为了颜色而颜色。另外情节也的确很烂。
Huaren
等级贵宾大校
威望53
贴子13584
魅力19563
注册时间2004-02-04

瓜子

只看他

2004-09-13 17:52:00

还没看过,又落伍了~~
Huaren
等级少尉
威望2
贴子1742
魅力2644
注册时间2003-10-24

particle

只看他

2004-09-14 20:30:00

十面埋伏是不是又要去奥斯卡了?
Huaren
等级三等兵
威望--
贴子82
魅力107
注册时间2004-02-05

jjwwsw

只看他

2004-09-14 21:00:00

hero is not so bad...
ADVERTISEMENT
Huaren
等级贵宾大校
威望165
贴子109088
魅力124870
注册时间2004-07-29

疏影暗香

只看他

2004-09-14 21:00:00

以下是引用mimiyian在2004-9-13 17:16:37的发言:
以下是引用Chanel在2004-9-13 14:53:55的发言:

再好看也抵不上情节烂呀
我在国内看得
基本上电影院就是从头笑到尾
尤其后面“交党费”死不了那段


I guess this movie, just like "Hero", is not meant for Chinese audience, but for international viewers.

It is just a movie meant for "export".

Maybe the success of "crouching tiger, hidden dragon" makes Zhang realize this type of movie can really sell!
There is no need of a good script, no need to make sense, but only need,
1. plenty of KongFu,
2. a love story,
3. beatuiful scenery, focus on BAMBOO forest! as they are considered to be exotic and unusual.
and therefore BAMBOO fighting (not sure whether people are already sick of this).
4. oversimpified historical events so that it won't be too changlendging for simple-minded foreign audience.


但卧虎是有情节的啊, 情节还很丰富, 讲了挺多事, 好歹也是根据一个小说改编的. 人物塑造性格也挺鲜明的, 虽然很多人不喜欢那个女主角性格, 但好歹人家也表现出那人物的性格了.
这埋伏算是个什么烂情节, 他以为是HK拍肥皂剧哪, 今晚上写出下一集剧本第二天早上就开拍, 拍到哪算哪, 把主角写死了算完.
初始化编辑器...

到底了