ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
littlesea
有2011年把traditional IRA convert成Roth IRA的同志吗?报税碰到麻烦了
3258
14
2012-02-22 01:50:00
TurboTax说我income太高,不能有Roth IRA. 要我要不交penalty, 要不把Roth IRA convert回traditional IRA.
不是去年不管income如何都可以convert吗?怎么会这样?
有没有这种情况的同志?税表怎么填啊?
不是去年不管income如何都可以convert吗?怎么会这样?
有没有这种情况的同志?税表怎么填啊?
我的Roth是去年开的,以前没有的。
以下是引用newacct在2/22/2012 4:50:00 PM的发言:
“开”是什么意思?你说过这些钱是从traditional ira convert过去的,不是直接放进去的,对不对?我不知道TurboTax问你什么;但是如果他问你有没有contribute进去你的Roth,答案应该是没有,因为是convert的。
=======
没说清楚。钱是从traditional IRA convert过去的,我没有自己开过Roth IRA。
TurboTax问我有没有contribute去我的Roth,我回答的是没有。可是之后TurboTax还是说我超过收入限制,不能拥有Roth IRA,要我把钱convert回去traditional IRA,或者每年交6%penalty。
大家都没碰到这个问题吗?看来是我什么地方填错了,今晚再好好检查一下。
“开”是什么意思?你说过这些钱是从traditional ira convert过去的,不是直接放进去的,对不对?我不知道TurboTax问你什么;但是如果他问你有没有contribute进去你的Roth,答案应该是没有,因为是convert的。
=======
没说清楚。钱是从traditional IRA convert过去的,我没有自己开过Roth IRA。
TurboTax问我有没有contribute去我的Roth,我回答的是没有。可是之后TurboTax还是说我超过收入限制,不能拥有Roth IRA,要我把钱convert回去traditional IRA,或者每年交6%penalty。
大家都没碰到这个问题吗?看来是我什么地方填错了,今晚再好好检查一下。
谢谢楼上的。我的TurboTax有点不一样。
income section
- 填1099-R的信息
其中2a一栏是5000,2b一栏是"Taxable Amount Not Determined"
填完这两栏Federal Tax Due就涨了2000多. 放在traditional IRA里的5000块钱是我税后的钱,怎么会又要交一次税呢?感觉不太对劲。
- Did You Inherit This IRA? No
- Let's Check For Any Rollovers or Conversions: I converted over this distribution: I converted the entire distribution of $5000 from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA.
- Move Funds? No
填完这个以后,跳出来A Few Last Things About Your Retirement Account(s)
- Have you made any non-deductible contributions to any IRA?
我选的yes,不知道对不对。
- Total basis as of December 31, 2010
0
- Value of your Traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRAs on December 31, 2011
0
- Value of your Roth IRAs on December 31, 2011
XXXX (some number)
- Explain your Recharacterization
...
- Did you have any of these Canadian retirement situations in 2011?
No
Deductions and Credits那里
- Contributions to an IRA or Roth IRA:
Traditional IRA
- Is This a Repayment of a Retirement Distribution?
No
- Your total 2011 traditional IRA contributions
5000
- Any Excess IRA Contributions Before 2011?
No
- Have you made any non-deductible contributions to any IRA?
Yes
- Total basis as of December 31, 2010
0
- Your income is too high to contribute
continue
- You currently have a penalty
Because you made an excess contribution of $5000 to your Roth IRA, you will owe a 6%
penalty ($265) each year that excess money remains in the IRA.
But don't worry. You can remove this penalty by taking action before April 17, 2012.
income section
- 填1099-R的信息
其中2a一栏是5000,2b一栏是"Taxable Amount Not Determined"
填完这两栏Federal Tax Due就涨了2000多. 放在traditional IRA里的5000块钱是我税后的钱,怎么会又要交一次税呢?感觉不太对劲。
- Did You Inherit This IRA? No
- Let's Check For Any Rollovers or Conversions: I converted over this distribution: I converted the entire distribution of $5000 from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA.
- Move Funds? No
填完这个以后,跳出来A Few Last Things About Your Retirement Account(s)
- Have you made any non-deductible contributions to any IRA?
我选的yes,不知道对不对。
- Total basis as of December 31, 2010
0
- Value of your Traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRAs on December 31, 2011
0
- Value of your Roth IRAs on December 31, 2011
XXXX (some number)
- Explain your Recharacterization
...
- Did you have any of these Canadian retirement situations in 2011?
No
Deductions and Credits那里
- Contributions to an IRA or Roth IRA:
Traditional IRA
- Is This a Repayment of a Retirement Distribution?
No
- Your total 2011 traditional IRA contributions
5000
- Any Excess IRA Contributions Before 2011?
No
- Have you made any non-deductible contributions to any IRA?
Yes
- Total basis as of December 31, 2010
0
- Your income is too high to contribute
continue
- You currently have a penalty
Because you made an excess contribution of $5000 to your Roth IRA, you will owe a 6%
penalty ($265) each year that excess money remains in the IRA.
But don't worry. You can remove this penalty by taking action before April 17, 2012.
什么是recharacterization?我还以为convert就是recharacterization了?
谢谢解释,原来是这样。
现在TurboTax叫我Explain your Recharacterization的地方我就不填了,全部留空。这样的话,就跟你的一样,说我不qualify IRA deduction,但是没再说我不能make Roth IRA contribution了,那个penalty的问题也没有了。
现在就剩下一个问题,我放到traditional IRA里的钱是我税后的钱,可是1099-R上的Box 2a (Taxable amount)显示的还是5000,虽然Box 2b (Taxable amount not determined)也是checked的。这1099-R不是自相矛盾嘛。我把1099-R填到income section后,要交的税立刻涨了2000多。我这5000块是税后的钱,怎么会又要交一次税呢。不知道是不是我哪里又填错了。
现在TurboTax叫我Explain your Recharacterization的地方我就不填了,全部留空。这样的话,就跟你的一样,说我不qualify IRA deduction,但是没再说我不能make Roth IRA contribution了,那个penalty的问题也没有了。
现在就剩下一个问题,我放到traditional IRA里的钱是我税后的钱,可是1099-R上的Box 2a (Taxable amount)显示的还是5000,虽然Box 2b (Taxable amount not determined)也是checked的。这1099-R不是自相矛盾嘛。我把1099-R填到income section后,要交的税立刻涨了2000多。我这5000块是税后的钱,怎么会又要交一次税呢。不知道是不是我哪里又填错了。
我发现把Total basis as of December 31, 2010填成5000(不是0),就不用给这5000块交税了。
初始化编辑器...
到底了
ADVERTISEMENT
Hot Deals
All DealsFSyueyun 双层浴室台面置物架,仅售 $12.72!
Farfetch时尚促销低至5折
Uniqlo 優衣庫嬰兒和兒童服飾特賣低至$7.9起
Carter's 清仓特卖新款加入,$2.99起包邮
THE OUTNET 男士特卖:额外最高可享40%折扣
Columbia儿童鞋冬季特卖,高达56%折扣
YOOX黑色星期五时尚促销,高达80%折扣
woot!来自Vitamix、Omega等品牌的榨汁机和搅拌机,折扣高达65%
Sandro Paris 男士闪购,低至2折
Longchamp限时特卖,低至五折
Gap Factory 儿童保暖服饰低至 5 折优惠
28%折扣PAISHENKEJI电动盐和胡椒研磨器套装 - $23.67(原价$32.99)- 黑色星期五特惠,免运费和退货!
28%折扣 MSMK 9件套不粘锅 – $119.20(原价$165) – 完美烹饪,抗刮擦,耐高温!
ADVERTISEMENT