Robert Shiller, a Yale economist and author of "Irrational Exuberance," which predicted the stock price collapse in 2000, has recently turned his eye to house prices. Between 1890 and 2004 he finds that real house returns would've been zero if not for two brief periods: one immediately following World War II and another since about 2000. (More on them in a moment.) Even if we include these periods houses returned just 0.4% a year, he says.

The average pundit, planner, lender or broker making the case for ownership doesn't look at returns since 1890. Sometimes they reduce the matter to maxims about "building equity" and "paying yourself" instead of "throwing money down the drain." If they do look at returns they focus on recent ones. Those tell a different story.

Between World War II and 2000 house prices
beat inflation by about two percentage points a year. (Stocks during that time beat inflation by their usual seven percentage points
a year.) Since 2000 houses have outpaced
inflation by six percentage points a year. (Stocks have merely matched
inflation.)

The average pundit, planner, lender or broker making the case for ownership doesn't look at returns since 1890. Sometimes they reduce the matter to maxims about "building equity" and "paying yourself" instead of "throwing money down the drain." If they do look at returns they focus on recent ones. Those tell a different story.

Between World War II and 2000 house prices
beat inflation by about two percentage points a year. (Stocks during that time beat inflation by their usual seven percentage points
a year.) Since 2000 houses have outpaced
inflation by six percentage points a year. (Stocks have merely matched
inflation.)